Skip to main content

How many lines of code is ideal for your program?

While looking at the refactoring project over on SednaX, I found myself writing up some quick little code analyzer classes designed to see whether or not a function should be refactored or not.

Looking at that chart, it shows FoxPro has some numbers like 35 single lines of code per function. Wow - that seems low but maybe not.

So tell me - what do you consider to be the ideal number of lines per code / function for readability, maintainability in your programs?




Take the Poll and let me know...


Comments

Anonymous said…
I must be insane and hard to work with. That's all I can think of.

I've picked up a contract working on a VFP project where there is one main VCX with a bunch of classes inside of it. There is another VFP programmer that checks this VCX and VCT in and out of VSS. We are both doing development on our own copies of this VCx at the same time. THis class has methods/functions are huge with hundreds of lines of code, that were already ther and need refactoring.

When we "merge" our changes, it ends up being me that has to redo my edits into his master copy of the VCX. (Beyond Compare takes care of merging the PRG based changes.)

I had refactored some of his mega functions so I could use a subsection of the code and it caused a minor problem when they had to rush all of our changes into production because of another emergency.

I recently suggested that we break the big VCX into a VCX per class to ease checkin/checkouts, version control, and development. The response was "Not ready to break up the vc*, we have enough trouble getting bugs out of what we do breaking into separate functions."

I must be insane and difficult to work with.
Andrew MacNeill said…
not if you look at the results of the poll. Seems like most like the idea of fewer lines per piece.

Popular posts from this blog

Well, that explains CodePlex...

In a move that will be sure to anger open source (or rather anti-paid software, anti-Microsoft open source)  zealots, Microsoft is planning to buy GitHub . A year ago, I mused about why Microsoft would shut down CodePlex and how the world needs competing source code repositories to be strong. I'm not the only one per this Slashdot article  : "...   people have warned about GitHub becoming as large as it did as problematic because it concentrates too much of the power to make or break the open source world in a single entity, moreso because there were valid questions about GitHubs financial viability...." - Jacques Mattheij I will be interested in seeing this play out - whether developers jump ship or not. Have all the efforts Microsoft has made in pushing towards open source be seen as genuine or will all the zealots jump ship or maybe even attack? Microsoft's comment about why they shut down CodePlex referred to how spammers were using CodePlex. Well, GitHub

Attending Southwest Fox 2019 could change your life - Find out how

Southwest Fox is coming up in October and as I do every year, I spoke with the organizers Rick , Doug and Tamar on the FoxShow. Deadlines for Southwest Fox: Super-saver price (before July 1): $695 Early-bird price (before August 1): $770 Regular price (August 1 and later): $820 This year, I took a different approach with separate shows for each organizer but the main message is still the same : July 1st is their Go/No-Go date. Conferences don't talk about this very often. I don't think developers really question if Apple will hold their WWDC in June or Microsoft will hold their Build conference - but that's because those conferences are vendor-led. Southwest Fox is a community-driven conference - it's not driven by a company with an agenda. Listen to the interviews and you can hear how important each of the organizers feel the live connection between speakers and among attendees.

eero icons - What the heck?

How to change icons used by eero.... Formerly titled: Eero router - Nicknames and icons UPDATE: Finally!!!! The most recent update to the eero now allows you to specify icons from their library. And it's a GOOD library - thank you. Finally! If you've extended your wireless network using eero , you have downloaded the app. I upgraded my network when I noticed a bunch of dead spots in what should have been a fairly reasonable coverage space (1700 sqft home). With two eero devices, our home is pretty well covered. Click on Connected devices and every device connected to your network is displayed. The eero app identifies the manufacturer and, with some devices, even the name of a given device. The eero app may also show an icon that represents its use. Some of the more obvious icons are those for phones, laptops and TVs. Unfortunately, the majority of devices get a fairly generic "wifi" icon. But you can change this. Give devices a nickname using ce